the stuff i got for my industrial contains:
W V De-ionised water
Glycerin
Sodium chloride
arnica
panthanol
cetrimide
citric acid
good ? bad?
Bad, because there is sodium chloride which is another word for SALT!
We looked for Panthanol and its spelled Panthenol and is used as a moisturizing agent in shampoos and conditioners, again, BAD, not good for a piercing.
Cetrimide has antibacterial and cleansing properties and is used for general antiseptic purposes but not for routine handwashing. Avoid contact with middle ear, the eyes. Avoid use in body cavities. So far we would not recommend using this product because one of the side effects is skin irritation. It is not to be used routinely and not near the ear.
The other ingredients are not going to have an adverse effect but because of the harshness of the above ingredients, please DO NOT USE THIS PRODUCT!